The Paleo Diet Debunked?

We’re big fans of the Paleo Diet around these parts.

If you’re not familiar with it, essentially it’s a ‘lifestyle choice’ of consuming certain foods based on we’re how we’re allegedly designed to eat from an evolutionary standpoint.

In short: cut out processed foods and grains, load up on veggies, meat, fish, eggs, fruits and nuts.

It’s no shock that Paleo is a hot topic around the Nerd Fitness Rebellion: our Beginner’s Guide to the Paleo Diet has been viewed over three million times and our iPhone App, Paleo Central, has already helped over 25,000 people make more informed decisions on what to eat.

Now, as this way of life has continued to grow in popularity, it seems like more and more critics are coming out of the woodwork to bash it and present arguments as to why the Paleo Diet is a fallacy.

Within the past few months, a TEDx talk on debunking the Paleo Diet has been making its way around the internet, and a recently released book, PaleoFantasy, has brought the “is this Paleo Diet a fad/dangerous/a waste of time?” to the front of the conversations throughout the blogosphere and mainstream media.

Being the nerd that I am, I wanted to respectfully address the most common arguments, explain my experiences with the diet, and then invite you to share your story too.

Let’s do this thing!

The Paleo Lifestyle isn’t realistic

caveman wall painting

First and foremost, critics love to point out that literally living a Paleo lifestyle is impossible in this day and age.

If we’re going to eat like cavemen, then certainly we should want to be living like them as well, right? Strapping on loin cloths, hanging out in caves, foraging for our own food, hunting our own animals, giving up modern day luxury and moving back to a primitive lifestyle.

Here’s the truth: Nobody I know who follows Paleo principles actually wants to live that way! Yeah, we can’t go hunt wooly mammoths or gazelles, so we do the best we can by consuming grass fed beef or bison, free range chicken, wild fish, and so on.

It’s absolutely true that modern day food is different from the food that existed tens of thousands of years ago, so we do the best we can with what we have.  

Ultimately, Paleo people aim to do the best we can to live like we’re genetically designed to live, while also having fun and enjoying the modern luxuries of today’s conveniences.

I love technology as much as the next nerd, and I have no intention on living in a cave any time soon.  I’d certainly consider a hobbit hole, but for now I’ll stick with my apartment.

So, almost nobody takes the “Paleo Lifestyle” literally – it’s instead looked at as a simple blueprint to give us the best chance at having success with weight loss and optimal health.

How we eat isn’t the problem, it’s because we don’t move enough

  Currently, roughly 70% of the United States is overweight.  Many health professionals assume that in order for us to turn our lives around, we simply need to be exercising more (at least 60-90 minutes per day) and eating less.  Changing up our diet and abandoning food groups like “heart healthy” whole grains is a waste of time, and that we need to just focus on calorie deficits to lose weight and get things back under control.

Unfortunately, in my research and studies on this topic I haven’t found this to tell the whole story: I firmly believe that our diet is responsible for 80-90% of our success or failure when it comes to weight loss or optimal health (exercise plays just a supporting role), that we CANNOT outrun our fork, and that all calories are NOT created equal.

I’ve found these articles found them both incredibly interesting and worth a read, explaining that just moving more isn’t enough, and that all calories are not created equal.

  • A Tanzanian hunter-gatherer tribe was tracked over a series of months.  Despite spending hours upon hours each day exercising, they showed no more energy expenditure than somebody who lived a far more sedentary lifestyle.  This suggests that our bodies adjust to the stresses put upon them and adjust how we spend our energy accordingly; just moving more without changing our diet won’t result in long term success/health.
  • Rats fed high fructose corn syrup gained significantly more weight  than rats fed the same number of calories of table sugar.  Not all sugar is created equal, and not all calories are created equal.  Though, it’s not a stretch to believe that a 200 calorie Twinkie will not produce the same results in your body as 200 calories of broccoli.

The Paleo Diet is mainly meat based

Shouldn't you be woolly?

Most critics love to point out that the Paleo Diet is “mainly meat based” (as stated in the TEDx talk referenced above and in this Huffington Post piece).  They then spend the rest of their talk/article explaining that we, in fact, didn’t eat all meat, and that we mostly ate plants!

And thank goodness! As the internet has recently pointed out, meat will kill you (actually, it won’t).

Although some people may choose to follow the Paleo Diet by eating primarily meat, and yes a majority of the protein consumed on a Paleo Diet does come from animal sources, I would argue that a true Paleo Diet is actually mostly vegetable based, supplemented by a protein source which often happens to be meat.  So, the critics and advocates of the Paleo Diet are in agreement on this – mostly plants!

Paleo and Atkins are not synonyms. People that are all-in on a Paleo Diet tend to have 2/3rds of their plate filled up with vegetables, and a small portion of meat added. Yes, some people choose to eat more meat than that, but nowhere in the basic Paleo principles does it state that Paleo Diet is mainly meat based.

A diet that promotes the consumption of more vegetables, and whenever possible eating meat from pasture raised or free range animals?

Sounds like something we can all be in agreement on.

But ancient humans ate grains!

wheat field

Here’s another argument that people love to point out:

Recently, some studies have popped up on various ancient cultures that show that some humans in certain civilizations consumed certain types of grains as far back as 100,000 years ago).

But wait! If the whole point of the Paleo Diet is that humans haven’t evolved much since the Agricultural Revolution (10,000 years ago)…and now you’re telling me that some humans ate grains further back than that, then how does the Paleo Diet make sense??

Shouldn’t this be causing mass hysteria among the paleo camp?

We’re missing the point here. The point is that processed grains, stuff in boxes and bags, is crap. No matter how far back you go in our evolutionary timeline, you’ll never find any ancient human eating dyed white bread or Lucky Charms (now with “heart healthy whole grains!”).  We need to be focusing on eating unprocessed, real food.

THIS is the point.  Not “no grains no matter what ever ever!” – but rather a common sense approach to cutting out processed foods and including more natural whole foods.

We are still evolving

caveman spaceman

A big cornerstone of the Paleo Diet is that humans haven’t evolved drastically since the Agricultural Revolution occurred 10,000 years ago.

Critics argue that we have in fact evolved since then, and that certain cultures have adapted to be able to consume grains or dairy, proving that we are evolving and that the Paleo Diet is no longer valid.

Again, we’re missing the point here: I also believe that we are still evolving. For example, people of Northern European descent tend to have no problem consuming dairy, while people of Asian descent tend to have issues digesting lactose and are often lactose intolerant: it’s because humans have evolved over time to adapt to their surroundings!

The truth is, a lot of people ARE gluten intolerant or lactose intolerant. In fact, at least  65% of the population has “a reduced ability to digest lactose after infancy,” and a growing number of people are discovering they’re gluten intolerant.

So, the Paleo Diet helps make people aware of two food groups that many people tend to have an issue with. I don’t think it should come as a surprise then to realize that these are the two food groups introduced most recently into our diets from an evolutionary standpoint.

It would seem that although a portion of the population adapted to consume more starchy/carbohydrate rich diets, it’s far from being a majority; same goes for dairy consumption.

But this study shows that a _________ diet is better

lego veggies

I tend to receive a few emails a week from concerned people who cite books like The China Study or other studies claiming that a plant only diet/low fat diet/fruit only diet/bicycle only diet is the path for optimal health, not Paleo.

To these, I reply: If it works for you, if you are getting a clean bill of health from your doctor, and if you are happy, by all means keep eating that way!  It’s clearly working for you.

I don’t think there is one particular diet that works for everybody – we all have intolerances to certain things or proclivities to others.  I WOULD argue that these studies always tend to mistake correlation for causation (as demonstrated by this refute of the China Study and its findings).

 I encourage people to assume NOTHING, and to always wear skeptic goggles when reading studies.

Here’s an example: these studies often compare vegetarian lifestyles to regular people who say they consume meat.  Somebody that has chosen to live a vegetarian lifestyle tends to be a more health conscious individual than the average bear, and thus aims to make healthier lifestyle choices all around (including exercise and eliminating certain types of unhealthy foods). This group of people is compared to people in the  “meat consumption” category (everyone else), who may or may not want to be living a healthier life, who may not exercise, who may not eliminate certain foods, who may partake in other unhealthy activities, and so on.

The truth of the matter is that there are very few studies that compare a health conscious plant-only diet to a health conscious Paleo Diet (containing grass fed beef, organic chicken, organ meats, and lots and lots of vegetables).  This is the first I’ve found.

If you are against the consumption of meat, more power to ya. If you look good, feel good, and wake up happy – keep doing what you’re doing, because it works for you.

However, if you are worried about consuming this or that due to a particular study, I would advise you to do your research on the study, create your own hypothesis, and conduct an experiment on yourself to find out what works for you!

Use these studies as a starting point for your own research.

Why I believe the Paleo Diet works

solo caveman

Here’s my humble, nerdy opinion as to why the Paleo Diet is so popular and helps so many people have success:

It’s not because ancient humans didn’t eat grains (they might have in small quantities); it’s not because we haven’t evolved (I’d argue that we have never stopped), nor because the diet encourages excessive meat consumption (if anything, it encourages excessive vegetable consumption).  Heck, we can’t be exactly sure what people ate 100,000 years ago (until Doc gets the DeLorean up and running), but that honestly doesn’t matter.

I believe the Paleo Diet works for a number of reasons, the most important being something that has nothing to do with anthropology or physiology:

It’s not just because the Paleo Diet teaches your body to use stored fat for energy rather than sugar.  Nor is it just because it’s very difficult to overeat on the Paleo Diet, which almost always leads to weight loss.  It’s not just because it can help with things like diabetes and other physiological issues (like multiple sclerosis).

It’s because it’s damn simple to understand, makes logical sense, removes the need for counting calories, and removes willpower from the equation. Just like a workout, the pretty good routine you follow is better than the perfect one you don’t. Similarly, the Paleo Diet isn’t perfect, but it works for many and it’s easy to follow.

Here’s why: willpower is a finite resource.

How many times have you told yourself “I’ll just have one” or “okay, I’ll only eat half of this” before eating the entire box/bag/entire serving?  Sugary/processed foods can have very addicting qualities, and for people who have addictive personalities (I’d imagine a HUGE portion of Nerd Fitness readers fit into this category), portion control can be incredibly challenging.

Having “just one” is a recipe for disaster, as your brain starts to think “ugh, why are you depriving me of this food that I so desperately want? I just tasted it and now I can’t think about anything else?!”

When you continue to consume unhealthy foods and you have this type of personality, you are a slave to your taste buds and the dopamine released after indulging yourself – your brain has a one-track mind and wants to consume the food you’re only allowed “one of.”

Compare this to somebody on the Paleo Diet.  Instead of “I can’t eat that food,” you say “I don’t eat that food” (as it’s not on the list of approved Paleo foods).  It has become part of your identity, and you need much less willpower to resist that temptation to consume (and most likely over-consume.

Thanks to my friend James Clear for this:

A research study divided people into two groups: one group was told that each time they were faced with a temptation, they would tell themselves “I can’t do X.” For example, when tempted with ice cream, they would say, “I can’t eat ice cream.”  The second group was  told to say “I don’t do X.” For example, when tempted with ice cream, they would say, “I don’t eat ice cream.”

As each student walked out of the room and handed in their answer sheet, they were offered a complimentary treat. The student could choose between a chocolate candy bar or a health bar. As the student walked away, the researcher would mark their snack choice on the answer sheet.

The students who told themselves “I can’t eat X” chose to eat the chocolate candy bar 61% of the time. Meanwhile, the students who told themselves “I don’t eat X” chose to eat the chocolate candy bars only 36% of the time. This simple change in terminology significantly improved the odds that each person would make a more healthy food choice.

By removing the mental work from the equation, the Paleo Diet puts you back in control, takes out the guess work required to figure out how much exactly to eat,  and eliminates the temptation associated with only having ‘a few’ of something.

The Paleo Diet works because the procedure is easy to follow and to build as a habit…not because it gives away some super secret diet formula…but because it’s simple and thus easy to adhere to.

Do I follow the Paleo Diet?

Steve Elephant

Although I’m a big fan of the Paleo Diet, I make a conscious decision to not follow it 100%.  

Instead, I have adapted the Paleo principles to my life and altered them to fit my lifestyle and goals.

Here’s why: setting aside the fact that there is no one true “Paleo Diet,” whenever I go full Paleo I tend to lose weight very quickly, dropping my body fat percentage down into the 7-8% range.  Personally, my goals these days are to add size and muscle, and improve my athletic performance.  In order for me to do that, I need to be putting ON weight, so I will mix in some non-Paleo foods like whole milk, rice, and oats depending on my training routine for that day.

On top of that, I’ll occasionally eat unhealthy foods, generally around social events, and not think twice about it!  Although it’s possible to eat healthy at a barbecue, I choose not worry about it, drink beer and eat pizza with everybody else, and then get back on track with my next meal.

So, although I don’t follow the Paleo Diet 100%, I’d argue that this is yet another example that shows that it works – when I want to put on weight, I add back in grains and dairy to my diet. When I go full Paleo, I lose body fat quickly and get even more lean, which is the same way Saint got his results after years of struggle.  I know NF Team member Staci is the same way: she constantly adjusts her Paleo “percentage” based on her athletic goals at that time.

The best solution?

Steve NF

I’m in the process of putting together a formal “Nerd Fitness Diet,” that will explain my entire philosophy on what to eat and what not to eat, and when to eat..

Rather than a rigid set of yes’s and no’s, it’ll instead be a simple set of guidelines to live by.  

I’ll be expanding upon this topic in a future article, but these are the rules that I believe will help you have the most success with weight loss, a healthy checkup from the doctor, and happy life:

  • EAT REAL FOOD. The less ingredients, the less steps it took to process, the healthier it will most likely be for you.
  • Minimize consumption of grains and dairy if your goal is weight loss.  Consider eliminating foods completely and then add them back in after a few weeks to see how your body responds.    
  • Understand that you can’t outrun your fork. Your diet will account for 80% of your success or failure.
  • Eat more vegetables.  No, corn doesn’t count :)
  • Try to consume 1 gram of protein per pound of lean body weight each day.
  • Minimize liquid calories.
  • Don’t have cheat meals – instead, make conscious decisions when to eat ‘unhealthy foods’ and then get right back on track.
  • Focus on building permanent small changes rather than sweeping changes that only last for a few weeks.
  • Relax! Do the best you can with what you have, where you are.

Have you tried it?

Lego Sherlock

I often find that those who are overly critical of the Paleo Diet have never actually given it a shot, nor tested for themselves how their body responds to these changes.

I encourage EVERYBODY to think for themselves and question everything – it’s even one of the Rules of the Rebellion!  I also encourage everybody to understand how their body works by getting hard facts whenever possible.  Take the time, save up the few bucks required, and get your blood work done. Then change your diet for 30-60 days and get blood work done again. See how your body reacts!

Not interested in getting blood work done?  Then go with look and feel – spend 30 days trying out a new diet, take before/after pictures and measurements, and compare how you feel (energy levels, exhaustion, etc.) before drawing your own conclusions.

I’d love to hear from you:

What are your thoughts on the Paleo Diet?  

Have you tried it?  What were your results?

If you’re against it, what are your concerns?

Leave a comment and let’s get the conversation started!  As always, thanks for keeping things civil :)


PS – If you are interested in the Paleo Diet and want more information, check out our Beginner’s Guide to the Paleo Diet which links to a number of great resources. If you want even more direction, our Nerd Fitness Guides are grounded in Paleo principles, applied in a way that you can slowly make changes rather than going all in. Cheers!


photos: caveman fast food, caveman wall painting, cat on treadmill, wooly mammoth, wheat, caveman spacemanlego veggiessolo caveman, steak and asparagus, lego sherlock.

Sharing is caring: Share on Facebook8,114Share on Google+96Tweet about this on Twitter187Email this to someone

Get The Rebel Starter Kit

Enter your email and we’ll send it right over.

  • The 15 mistakes you don’t want to make.
  • The most effective diet and why it works.
  • Complete your first workout today, no gym required.
  • These are the tools you need to start your quest.
  • Courtney

    How do you recommend going Paleo on a college budget?

  • Noelle

    So far I’ve lost 39 lbs following Paleo. I feel great, eating clean feels better. I haven’t even started working out. . .yet. The funny thing is I’m only about 7 lbs below when I originally lost all my weight the first time (before pregnancy) and people are saying how much MORE weight I’ve lost. I really believe it’s because Paleo reshapes your body. I can definitely tell differences, I finally have a waist!

  • Brad

    Started Paleo 8 months ago, I am down 65 pounds. I continually adjust the diet following the Paleo principles which as helped me stick with it. I now am so much more conscious of what goes in my my mouth. It simply works, and I seldom crave bad food.

  • devouringone3

    Maybe it is because your not looking at the organisms which do most of the digestion and enable nutrient absorption in the first place…

    “The human body carries about 100 trillion microorganisms in its intestines, a number ten times greater than the total number of human cells in the body.[2][3][4][5][6] The metabolic activities performed by these bacteria resemble those of an organ, leading some to liken gut bacteria to a “forgotten” organ.[7] It is estimated that these gut flora have around a hundred times as many genes in aggregate as there are in the human genome.[8]” []

    (Up to 60% of the dry mass of feces is live, swelling bacteria…)

    Those tiny animals living inside your integrated lunchbox, how fast are they reacting and adapting (“evolving”) to the agricultural revolution or the newest food at the store?

    Last time I checked, the sugar-reducing and protein-denaturing simple cauldron that is your stomach secreted two sorts of thing: hydrochloric acid and proteases. How specific is this process, can it even tell a sweet potato from a starchy one, a chestnut versus a spoonful of oat groats?

    Fiber strength and water weight are the two food properties my stomach seems to react the strongest to.

  • Jenn

    Steve, my problem with this is as much as you like to think you are eating a Paleo diet, you are not, so why not call the diet something else. And most of the people out there debunking the diet are anthropologists, evolutionary scientists, and other experts in the field. Not some fitness buff. It is a good diet poorly named.

  • Jenn

    Yes indeed. Veganism is not a diet one follows, it is a lifestyle that extends to choices beyond food. No animal derivatives (including honey) in any product they buy/use (soap, shoes, bags, etc..)

  • Melanie Kleiner

    Been trying to eat whole foods and lose weight and get healthier for the past year. Grains and potatos are my trigger foods for overeating. I notice when I avoid grains and opt for more veggies I have lost weight much easier and my joints don’t hurt so much. Also, I have noticed that when I eat legumes I don’t lose and sometimes gained. When I read your site about Paleo I saw the reasoning. So I know for me Paleo is the way to go (at least modified). I do use some dairy in the form of yogurt and some cheese also.

  • JoJo

    I completely agree. It makes so much sense. Although I think this article could provide some more information for vegetarians and vegans even though there are so many different types. Perhaps some alternatives to meat that don’t involve grains or dairy. And also some tips on how to go paleo, or partway paleo, while living with parents/being a teen. Many teens’ parents simply say no because they listen to the majority of people or what they’ve previously learned so something to convince parents would be great. Thanks!

  • Brian

    At the begining of the year I went full paleo for about 6 months in and I was down from 80 kgs to 70kgs and feeling and looking great.

    I’ve cut down on the paleo diet but stil following the principals this past couple of months and still feeling great.

    love the way of life and would recomend anyone who wants to loose weight and feel great.

  • Dr. Jones

    It’s an interesting topic but I found the article really lacking in scientific rigor. A lot of opinion statements in response to actual research. I guess I hoped for better than the usual opinion piece about a scientific subject from a place with Nerd in the title.


    Started today…

  • Nancy Ann Negrini-Smith

    The only problem I have with it is my half n half to go with my cup of coffee in the morning. I havent lost any weight yet and I have been doing paleo about 90% Any suggestions would be helpful. And no, Im not giving up my cup of coffee in the morning and no I’m not drinking it black. I do make my bread with coconut and almond flour. Should I give this up and just eat the strict paleo meals?

  • denise

    I felt good!! But like the others, I also have a hard time eating the “Paleo” way because of the people around me. They all eat high carbs and all the sat fat stuff. Thanks for your support!! hope more people will discover this new way of life!

  • Daniel Škubal

    Great article and I totally agree that Paleo diet is perfect according to my experience, but I would say everybody is different and can react to different things and raw food or any other diet is not a exception. We shouldn’t create a dogma. I can not say which diet is the best but I can say that so far raw food works the best for me since I was on normal diet, Paleo diet and now on raw food (all my allergies or even inflammation of the intestine is gone and doctors said I will be taking pills to the rest of my life). But there are definitely some negatives in regards of un-cooking, digestive problems or even right food intake in order you could get all nutrients to your body. Check out this article as well – 5 Negatives of Raw food diet below –

  • whothehell

    i think Paleo diet recommends meat, but does not enforce you to eat meat.
    A paleo diet based only on plants is also perfect as long as it works for you. But if someone wants to eat meant then, he/she can eat properly cooked farm meat.
    Congrats on your progress.

  • whothehell

    but our teeth is perfect for chewing/rending BBQed or cooked meat :)

  • Pingback: Is Fruit Healthy For You? | Nerd Fitness()

  • Cob Khuraibet

    The excessively smart people I know say that paleo works because it is clean, mindful eating and that little else about the paleo diet is proven or accepted within the scientific community. Having said that… clean, mindful eating is pretty much what Steve says it’s about.

  • Doug

    I love the idea of the Paleo diet. Even if it just means removing as much processed foods as possible. This is what I’m trying to do. More veggies and meat, less carbs in the evening meals, and a high protein breakfast after my morning workout. It seems to be works so far although I’ve only been on this new way of eating for a few weeks. I have noticed higher energy levels.

  • Pingback: Going Paleo? 5 Things You Need to Know. | Nerd Fitness()

  • Paige McAllister

    No, when you actually study the philosophy behind veganism, it all comes down to ethics. It has NOTHING to do with health, although there is a very compelling amount of research saying that vegans are the healthiest people on the planet. Anyways, to understand this viewpoint please reference the poster boy of the ethics of veganism – Peter Singer.

  • Chris

    Hi Steve, Great articles all around! I have slowly changed my diet and lifestyle over the last two years to one that is gluten free (I’m gluten intolerant), whole foods & organic w/ moderate exercise and activity along with quitting smoking. Cut out all wheat, refined sugars & processed foods. I do watch my calories to stay in check. My weight has dropped from 275lbs down to current 225lbs. My goal is 190lbs so I’m slowly keeping at it!

    The idea of Paleo is pretty new to me so I started looking in to it and came across your website and I’m hooked on NF! I’ve checked out the eat/don’t eat lists of paleo food groups. Really, the only non-paleo foods I’m eating are beans, brown rice, potatoes, a limited amount of cheese and some gluten free substitutes like GF bread, pasta and chips.

    I can easily understand why dairy and GF products are not Paleo and have started cutting down on them… but what about beans, brown rice and potatoes? Can you please explain why these three items are not considered Paleo? I know they are agricultural items but didn’t they exist before that time in the wild? Aren’t they natural/whole foods? Do you think cutting these remaining items out of my diet will help boost my weight lose progress and increase the overall health of my diet?

    Appreciate any & all insight you and NF community can offer!!! Thanks, Chris

  • truth

    Alcohol is beneficial and healthy for u in moderation. Its not a bad thing in and of itself as long as u dont use it as a sleep aide or drink it too close to bedtime.

  • Marina

    I just went paleo about two weeks ago and I’ve altered it to fit my needs. I’m a teenager and I’m still growing and all that so I need more starch, so I eat white rice and white potatoes every now and then. I also eat butter and ghee as I don’t have bad reactions to dairy as far as I know, and they’re the only fats I cook with. Honestly, I love the paleo lifestyle, I love that I don’t have to count calories and fuss about my food, and that I eat enough. But the best part is that all my friends are freaking out and transitioning from this fad diet to that fad diet and I’m just there like “yeah yeah great! Exercise more eat less haha yes you’ll be skinny in no time!” And inside im like “huehuehuehue >:)”

  • จมาพันธ์ ชูตา

    thank for good info i want to diet like this

    holiday palace / จีคลับ / คาสิโนออนไลน์

  • Kyle Karwan

    Ethical? I raise cows and to be honest the same number of cows are going to be slaughtered unless everyone stops eating meat. All being a vegan does is wastes the food that some man somewhere sunk his money and time and blood sweat and tears into. The farmers raise as many cows,pigs, fowl, whatever, that they can and all of it goes to the slaughterhouse. Animals don’t not die because someone doesn’t eat meat. It’s just more food for the meat eaters.

  • abc123

    I agree. Some saltman on another blog tried to say it was a terrible diet, but I knew that dude was bugging. He’s got the butters tbh.

  • Stella

    Hi Steve, I have been on Paleo for 4 weeks now and I don’t see any single improvement in my health and energy level. I have lost 2 pounds but I am very slender and weight is not the issue. I have learned to eat much more vegetables than before! I don’t like eating meat or fish or eggs everyday and I miss my quinoa, hummus and chickpeas terribly. It’s been a special experience but I’ll put some grains and beans back onto my plate.

  • rook

    You say there’s evidence pointing in the opposite direction? Sources?

  • Michael Craven

    Sure – there are plenty of studies now pointing particularly to tubers and other starches being a big part of human diet going back 20,000 years or more and newish studies in the Near East keep pushing back the date for human consumption of grasses. See Liu L, Bestel S, Shi J, Song Y, Chen X. Paleolithic human exploitation of plant foods during the last glacial maximum in North China. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2013;110(14):5380-5385. doi:10.1073/pnas.1217864110; Weiss E, Wetterstrom W, Nadel D, Bar-Yosef O. The broad spectrum revisited: Evidence from plant remains. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2004;101(26):9551-9555. doi:10.1073/pnas.0402362101; Yasuoka H. Dense Wild Yam Patches Established by Hunter-Gatherer Camps: Beyond the Wild Yam Question, Toward the Historical Ecology of Rainforests.Human Ecology. 2013;41(3):465-475. doi:10.1007/s10745-013-9574-z. Also, it should be noted that while humans evolve slowly, the make up of our micro biome is incredibly dynamic, thus making adaptation a bit easier. See: Quercia S, Candela M, Giuliani C, et al. From lifetime to evolution: timescales of human gut microbiota adaptation. Frontiers in Microbiology. 2014;5:587. doi:10.3389/fmicb.2014.00587. and Schnorr SL, Candela M, Rampelli S, et al. Gut microbiome of the Hadza hunter-gatherers. Nature Communications. 2014;5:3654. doi:10.1038/ncomms4654.

  • rook

    Wow! Thanks man, this is very useful.

    I think people really want to believe there is a universal dietary rule which will work for everyone (some of the hardcore paleo dieters subscribe to this). I think the author is trying to get across that this is a new way of doing things and for some, especially those whose dietary lifestyle experiments have failed them in the past, are looking for something they can try, and if it works, truly believe in. I am not sure, however, that he did a good job differentiating “universal lifestyle change that will work for everyone” from “a new, potentially beneficial lifestyle that will help some”.

    He does qualify some of the article with writing like this:

    “If it works for you, if you are getting a clean bill of health from your doctor, and if you are happy, by all means keep eating that way! It’s clearly working for you.”

    To me, those words imply that there are other ways of living and eating. Each person, and I imagine different groups of people, evolve differently. I’m glad you are part of the actual discussion rather than just spouting hate or blind trust in the paleo diet.

    Finally, I think the best way anyone can figure out what’s best for them is to use the scientific approach. Reading articles and researching is fine but actually living the paleo (or any other diet, for that matter), will hopefully give others the answer. Who’d I trust cutting down a tree next to my house? A lumberjack or a PhD in forestry and lumber-jacking (not an actual degree you can get I imagine, but you get my point)?

    Be pragmatic, do your research, and list to people like you, who are knowledgeable about opposing views. Pretty straight forward. Thanks again for your addition to the discussion.

  • James Driver

    I went Primal a la Mark Sisson rather than full Paleo about two years ago. Started off with a 21 day clean eating challenge and lost 6 kg (13 lbs) in that period starting at about 96 kg (211 lbs).

    My previous highest weight was about 105 kg (230 lbs) and lightest was about 86 kg (189 lbs) both when I was rowing surf boats in under 21’s. Back then, I could eat anything and lift heavy iron all winter to gain weight (unofficially ~340 squat and deadlift for singles, ~220 bench) and then just cut 30 lbs during the rowing season due to the sheer amount of activity. So I’ve always had some strength but roll on 15 years, a fight with cancer and now having two kids – I’ve been getting out of shape.

    I’ve had ups and downs since my challenge, but have still kept most of that original weight off. I had to buy new clothes and haven’t had to go back to the old ones.

    I changed my workouts from mostly swimming to body-weight training and was seeing good results. Work stress has built up recently plus we’ve moved office away from the best all-day omelette place in the city, add a gastro virus and I’m off track at the moment :(.

    I still avoid bread based breakfasts and potatoes, pasta and rice in general, but have let my guard down for cake and sweets during the work day. Or pasties/meat pies (I’m sure they’re a British/Australian thing).

    I like Paleo/Primal because it’s very much a one-meal/workout-at-a-time affair. You just have to say no to one piece of cake and it’s that much easier to say no to the next piece. Eat a raw carrot and decide to that again but eat some broccoli too. Do a set of squats and it gives you the motivation to go again in a couple of days.

    During my first primal transition, I was astounded at how much extra energy I had. I was chasing my kids ’round the playground and my wife’ round the… well let’s keep it PG 😉

    I recently watched Joe Cross’s “Fat, Sick and Nearly Dead” which documents a couple of guys going on vegetable juice diets. Sounds wacky, but through my primal lens, and considering the health issues they had, it didn’t seem such a weird thing to do – these guys had the fat stores to fuel their daily activities. And the film left me with the feeling that paleo, primal, atkins, vegan, whatever; a lot of the benefit of an eating system comes from not putting “non-foods” in your body, rather than splitting hairs about which real foods you do/don’t eat after deciding to stop throwing the junk in. Though I do hope Mr. Cross and his followers add some non-juiced food back into their diets after a period of vege-juice only.

    For me, the centerpiece of the paleo ethos is to call B@!!$hitt on the FDA food pyramid, the wheat lobby that created it and the manufactured foodstuff industry at large and say “that’s not a food, this (pastured beef/ an actual beetroot or avocado / eggs / even lard and tallow) is food!”

    Here in Australia, the mainstream is starting to turn down the paleo path. We’ve had local TV chefs publish paleo cookbooks, Our biggest supermarket chains are marketing free range chicken and grass-fed beef. Jamie Oliver (UK celebrity chef) only agreed to be a spokesman for one of them if they stopped selling meat from cage chickens.

    I think the paleo/primal message makes sense and it has improved my life. There’s food and non-food. Eat more of the things that are food. You only get one body. Use it or lose it, but don’t break it – marathons fall into the break it category for most.

  • anne

    I became paleo vegan after spending my life being a vegetarian that suddenly found them selves with hereditary diviticulitis, I’m 46 and after the first 30 days of sticking to it to the letter I now have a glass or 2 of wine a few times a week, finding that’s all I ever generally want and sticking to the p v diet most of the time, only if I go out for a meal will I eat vegetarian rather than paleo vegan. My results have been fantastic for me as I now feel well, my skin is amazing and I have more energy, so I agree whilst not for everyone it has worked for me, I have so far lost 11 kilos, which is getting me back to my doctor recommended weight, my diviticulitis is stable and I never want for the foods I now don’t eat even though I thought I would.

  • Aslanjr

    Great idea, thank you for share

    370 Paleo Recipes

  • Sharon Hooper

    There is no doubt that paleo diets are extremely effective as i’ve lost
    around 65 lbs in about a year and half. However, I really can’t
    emphasise the importance on getting a sustainable long term paleo diet
    plan that is not gonna have bad effects on your health. The best paleo
    diet cookbook (with planned diet regimes) I found is
    newsciencediet*com/paleo (obviously change the * to a dot as it wont let
    me post links here) and would highly recommend it to anyone looking to
    paleo diet! :)

  • Shelton King

    hey great article but check out this great article at

  • dmitri bogdanoch

    I began slowly transitioning into the paleo diet several months ago, made small changes and stuck with them.

    film streaming